The content should not be relied upon as legal advice and is not intended to create an attorney-client relationship.
An erotic communication between two people online via text, audio or video chat.
Online sex roleplay chat rooms
He was arrested when he arrived at a pre-arranged meeting place. However, in remanding the case, majority suggested the trial court reconsider the excluded expert testimony. The expert testimony would assist the jury since it was “unlikely that the average juror is familiar with the role-playing activity” and the expert could explain in the context of sexually oriented conversations on the Internet.
At his trial, he offered the expert testimony of a professor of clinical sexuality concerning online “fantasy characters” and role-playing in chat rooms and by e-mail. [a] major component of the entertainment on the Internet is the rapid repartee, in addition to having imaginative fun. Sexually explicit conversations tend to drive the chatting relationship, and are fueled by the anonymity of the created personas. The social science field was an area in which the Daubert factors involving peer review, publication, and potential error rates were not applicable.
Specifically, the defense proposed that the expert: “testify that . When engaging in Internet role-play, people love to experiment with their personas. Cross-examination could be used to expose weaknesses in the opinion. He noted that the expert testimony, even if relevant, could be excluded under FRE 403 as on grounds of “undue delay, waste of time, or needless presentation of cumulative evidence, ” particularly after the defendant testified to present his defense about role-playing.
Typically, people weave a bit of truth about themselves with a great deal of imagination and/or exaggeration. While it remains to be seen what the trial court will do on remand, if the majority view is applied in other cases, the door may be opened for other social science expert testimony concerning Internet practices.
The Internet presents [a] competitive entertainment. Maintain your advantage on evidence law by making it easier to use recent evidence cases in your practice.
Receive the Review delivered via the Internet in PDF format providing summaries, insight, and analysis on the evidence cases of the previous month.
Learn more presents information and opinions as an informational and educational service to visitors.
Block Script is security software which protects websites and empowers webmasters to stop unwanted traffic.
Your request was blocked because you appear to be accessing this website from a hosting provider network, proxy server, or VPN server.
After being arrested for using the Internet to solicit sexual activity with a person the defendant believed to be a minor, can the defendant present expert testimony about Internet “role-playing” to support his defense that he thought the person he communicated with on the Internet was an adult?
A divided Second Circuit panel recently addressed this issue and answered in the affirmative.